Welcome to the official website of performer, Samantha Sostarich. Please enjoy your browsing and thank you so much for visiting!

Annie is a Hit with Critics

Our first review is in from Milwaukee Journal Sentinel and “Annie” is a hit! Jim Higgins writes that “Annie” is “terrific,” “full of girl power,” and featuring a “masterpiece” ‘It’s the Hard Knock Life.'” Carrie Hitchcock “goes all in” on Hannigan while Diane Lane “is pure elegance as Grace.”

‘Annie’ brings a surge of girl power to the Skylight – Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

“‘70s musical seems to comment on today’s politics, in a Skylight show that shines.”

Oh, How New ‘Annie” Seems – Urban Milwaukee

“Carrie Hitchcock comically staggers through the halls of the orphanage as Miss Hannigan, lending her signature textured voice to the bitter lament ‘Little Girls.’ Joined by her brother Rooster (a suave and slick Matt Crowle) and his blonde bombshell girlfriend Lily St. Regis (a brazen Samantha Sostarich), the trio nearly stops the show with their ode to the perfect heist, ‘Easy Street.'”

At the Skylight’s “Annie,” the timeless redhead shows no risk of going grey – On Milwaukee

“With Carrie Hitchcock as Miss Hannigan and Matt Crowle as the ever-scheming Rooster and the always delightful Samantha Sostarich in a trio that had all the antagonism and mystery that every criminal enterprise needs. It was a crucial reminder for the audience that it wasn’t all sunshine and balloons in the world of Annie.”

The sun comes out, every night, in Skylight’s “Annie” – Dave Begel on Theater

“Spirited and heartwarming, Annie at The Skylight Music Theatre proves that Tomorrow is better and brighter than today, so don’t lose hope. This is the best gift we could ask for this holiday season.”


“As usual, Skylight has put together a very talented cast, full of Milwaukee favorites (these kids will knock your socks off!), and, of course, everyone loves a real dog on the stage. Fans of Annie will love the familiar songs, and the entire production builds an anticipation of the holiday season. This classic will feel like an instant holiday tradition, but it’s really quite a rare opportunity, so I suggest getting your tickets while you can!”

Annie at Skylight Music Theatre – Ozaukee Living Local

Annie Promo Videos

Fox 6 Wakeup Appearance for MAM

Did you catch our segments on Fox 6 Wakeup?

Learn a little more about a few of the characters you will meet this Friday evening at Milwaukee Art Museum After Dark’s Murder Mystery.

MAM After Dark Murder Mystery


Northwestern Mutual Presents
MAM After Dark
Fri, Oct 20, 7–11 PM
Join the Murder Mystery and experience the darker side of after dark.
Put on your detective hat, embrace your inner murder-mystery character—or simply leave the costumes to the suspects—and observe as a live game of Clue-like drama unfolds. Throughout the night, watch the scenes play out, and see if you can solve the crime. Follow updates on mam.org/afterdark for more clues leading up to the event.

Meet the suspects:
The Curator
The Auditor
The Celebrity
The Intern
The Donor
The Artist
The Mobster
Experience the soul-filled music of B~Free and Quinten Farr, with special guest Foreign Goods.
Visit the Bohemian Artist Den with Milwaukee Ballet, and try your hand at live figure drawing.
Learn the famous faces in the Museum’s Collection Galleries on Wild Card Tours, in anticipation of the upcoming modernist exhibition.
See and purchase for your own the colorful, dynamic works of local legend and 414 Artist Stacey Williams Ng.
Escape to the Café Calatrava Lounge for a spell with themed Prix Fixe Dining and Team Trivia with Quizmasters.
Continue the revelry at the MAM After Dark Official After Party, located at Whiskey Bar (788 N. Jackson St.)

AVOID THE LINES AS A VIP—VIP TICKETS (Advance Sales Only) | $30/$20 Museum Member
Upgrade your advance ticket to VIP for access to an exclusive lounge, featuring:
o Express event entrance
o Private cash bar
o Delightful tastings by Red Elephant Chocolate

$12 at the door | $10 in advance | FREE for Milwaukee Art Museum Members

(Advance Member tickets available online with donor ID; number allotted depends on your membership level: Dual/Family = 2, Individual/Student = 1. Member must be present at check-in.)

Get in FREE for a whole year—join today! Memberships start at just $35!
Join today!
Advance Tickets and Dining or Team Trivia Reservations Available now until Thurs, Oct 19, at 5 p.m. (or until the event reaches capacity).

King David in Concert

I’m excited to be singing the role of Bathsheba in Congregation Beth Israel Ner Tamid’s concert of Alan Menken and Tim Rice’s King David.

Learn More Here
Sunday, October 22
Congregation Beth Israel Ner Tamid
6880 N. Green Bay Avenue
Glendale, WI 53209
$18/General Admission

Call 414-352-7310 for more information.