Welcome!

Welcome to the official website of performer, Samantha Sostarich. Please enjoy your browsing and thank you so much for visiting!

Surprise, a UPAF Video Appearance

The Skylight Music Theatre and our production of The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee were happy to make an appearance in the United Performing Arts Fund promotional video for the 2020 fundraising campaign.

Skylight’s “Spelling Bee” is F-U-N

Elaine Schmidt, Special to the Journal Sentinel writes Skylight Music Theatre turns ‘Spelling Bee’ into a day of laughter

Gwendolyn Rice says Skylight’s “Spelling Bee” is F-A-N-T-A-S-T-I-C.
“Bizarre color commentary is provided by saccharine local realtor and bee alum Rona Peretti (Samantha Sostarich, complete with the fake smile of a beauty pageant contestant).”

Anne Segel of the Shepherd Express reviews that Skylight’s ‘Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee’ Gets an A!
“The cast members who play the adult roles include Skylight favorite Samantha Sostarich as a former spelling bee champ who serves as a judge; Robby McGhee as a somewhat unstable vice principal from a neighboring school, also a judge; and Shawn Holmes as a paroled convict who consoles the contest losers as part of his public service. All three actors double and sometimes triple their roles, displaying their versatility as artists.”

CTM’s Matilda the Musical is a Hit!

Reviewer Gwendolyn Rice says ““Roald Dahl’s Matilda the Musical” harnesses all of CTM’s abundant talent” and is a “sensational dystopia”.

“As Matilda’s equally horrifying mother, Samantha Sostarich is deliciously shallow, in gaudy hot pink and lime dresses (accessorized with pink glittery high heels!). Obsessed with winning ballroom dance contests and looking glamorous while she does it, Sostarich’s Mrs. Wormwood is aided by her sultry, faux Italian partner, Rudolpho (the suave Sam Taylor). Her brash, coarse ideology is perfectly on display in her personal anthem, “Loud.””

Read the full review HERE.

WE ARE GREEN BAY’s Warren Gerds Reviews LA LA LUCILLE’S Sold-Out Opening Night

“… an astounding re-imagining …”

“… all cylinders are go with this cast …”

“… great stuff in so many ways … ”

“The opening night audience latched on to the performers’ level of exhilaration and erupted in standing cheers and applause at the end.”

” Samantha Sostarich brims with energy and full-on expression as Lucille. She launches a HUGE note to end one number.”

(Read the full review HERE.)

LA LA LUCILLE runs through September 1st, Wed – Sat @ 7:30 and Sun @ 2:00.

ORDER TIX at www.thirdavenueplayhouse.com or call 920.743.1760 (T – F / noon – 5).

Warren Gerds/Critic at Large Checks in on La La Lucille


James Valcq gathers with the cast of “La La Lucille” to start rehearsals for George Gershwin’s “La La Lucille” that Valcq has revived. (Company photo)

“Warren Gerds/Critic at Large: 100-year treat in store in Sturgeon Bay for Gershwin’s ‘La La Lucille’”

“According to the website: This is George Gershwin’s first musical, which has not been staged since its Broadway premiere in 1919. The adaptation and restoration are by James Valcq, co-artistic director of Third Avenue Playhouse.

The farce tells the story of a married couple who plot to become temporarily divorced to claim an inheritance. When the scheme goes awry, hilarity, hijinks and tap dancing ensue.

“La La Lucille” includes Gershwin melodies that haven’t been heard in 100 years along with some that have never been performed.

The website elaborates:

The more amazing story is that much of the original music from this show was lost. It is only through the efforts of composer/director James Valcq, who has restored and reconstructed the complete score, that “La La Lucille” will be seen (and heard) again, exactly 100 years later.

It all started with a manila file folder.”

Read the full article HERE.