"The whole show is like a career showcase for Samantha Sostarich who, with each solo, justifies to be cast in the actual roles she sings." - Ryan Jay, RyanJayReviews.com "Sostarich, the do-everything glue person here, led one of the night's great moments: "Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious," with spectacular choreography
Elaine Schmidt, Special to the Journal Sentinel writes Skylight Music Theatre turns 'Spelling Bee' into a day of laughter Gwendolyn Rice says Skylight's "Spelling Bee" is F-A-N-T-A-S-T-I-C. "Bizarre color commentary is provided by saccharine local realtor and bee alum Rona Peretti (Samantha Sostarich, complete with the fake
Reviewer Gwendolyn Rice says "“Roald Dahl’s Matilda the Musical” harnesses all of CTM’s abundant talent" and is a "sensational dystopia". "As Matilda’s equally horrifying mother, Samantha Sostarich is deliciously shallow, in gaudy hot pink and lime dresses (accessorized with pink glittery high heels!). Obsessed with winning
Gwendolyn Rice from The Isthmus calls Four Seasons Theatre's Spamalot "Royal Hilarity - “Spamalot” captures the irreverent spirit of Monty PythonRoyal hilarity" "Christiaan Smith-Kotlarek’s gorgeous baritone as Sir Galahad is a great match for his duet partner, Samantha Sostarich and her killer soprano as the Lady
Gwendolyn Rice reviewed Goodnight Moon for the Isthmus. "As Mouse, Samantha Sostarich is Bunny’s playful companion in mischief. She lends her beautiful singing voice to the only ballad of the show, 'North Star'